The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Tuesday, May 21, 2013
 
Nazi Looted Paintings Discovered at Southern Methodist University
"Saint Justa" by Bartolome Esteban Murillo, Credit: Meadows Museum. (PRNewsFoto/Monuments Men Foundation, Meadows Museum)
DALLAS, TX.- Based on new evidence about the systematic looting of art from Jewish owners in the course of hostilities in Europe during World War II, a pair of famous paintings on display at SMU's Meadows Museum created by Spanish master Bartolome Esteban Murillo (1618-1682) of Seville's Patron Saints Justa and Rufina, estimated to be worth more than $10 million, are believed to have been stolen from the Rothschild family in Paris in 1941. The Nazi ERR (Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg) code evidencing Rothschild ownership is still visible on the stretcher bar of one of the paintings; it appears to have been rubbed off the other. The Monuments Men Foundation, recipient of the 2007 National Humanities Medal for its work preserving the legacy of these unknown heroes, which it received from the President of the United States at a White House ceremony, is continuing its research to document conclusively whether both paintings were properly restituted to the rightful owners prior to donation to the Meadows Museum.

These paintings, among tens of thousands looted by the Nazis, were later transported to Germany and Austria where they were discovered in the closing days of the war by the Monuments Men, a small group of men and women - museum directors, curators, artists, architects and librarians - who volunteered for service in an unprecedented effort to protect the great cultural treasures of western civilization from the destruction of the war and theft by the Nazis. This group, empowered by President Roosevelt and General Eisenhower, formally known as the Monuments, Fine Arts, and Archives section (MFAA), counted among its key members Lt. James J. Rorimer (future director of the Metropolitan Museum of Art), Private Lincoln Kirstein (future founder of the New York City Ballet), and Lt. George Stout (future director of the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum), among others.

Robert M. Edsel, Founder and President of the Monuments Men Foundation for the Preservation of Art, a not-for-profit organization dedicated to completing the mission of the Monuments Men, and author of a newly released book, The Monuments Men: Allied Heroes, Nazi Thieves, and the Greatest Treasure Hunt in History (Center Street, 2009), commented: "The Monuments Men Foundation is proud to announce that after more than two and a half years of effort, University officials at SMU/Meadows Museum have now publicly acknowledged the correct provenance of these two paintings by Murillo, and more importantly, have now, by recognizing the Nazi theft of the artwork on the museum's website, contemporaneously endorsed the "best practices" guidelines of both the American Association of Museums (AAM) and the Association of Art Museum Directors (AAMD). This is a milestone achievement for the Monuments Men Foundation in fulfilling this portion of its Mission Statement by encouraging all museums to comply with the commonly accepted guidelines concerning objects possibly looted by the Nazis. While we congratulate University officials on taking this important step, we underscore the importance of their completing provenance research on the entire collection and publicizing those results. Additionally, we hope they will promptly follow the recommendations of the AAM concerning placement of the information about the Murillos' Nazi provenance on the AAM's Nazi-Era Provenance Internet Portal (www.nepip.org), which was specifically designed to enable those victims of the Nazis' looting to have the fairest chance possible to locate and recover their belongings. During World War II, two Monuments Men who believed in that concept died during combat trying to protect works of art from the destruction of the war and theft by the Nazis. It is no less relevant today than it was 65 years ago." Mr. Edsel added: "The Foundation's research to confirm that these important paintings were properly restituted to the rightful owners prior to their acquisition by Mr. Meadows in 1972 continues."

The established procedures of the AAMD, of which the Meadows Museum is a member, make specific reference to the work of the Monuments Men during and after World War II "to facilitate the identification of works that were stolen by the Nazis and not restituted" and to "ensure continued transparency in the acquisition and presentation of collections". (To view that document, visit www.monumentsmenfoundation.org/user_docs/aamd_letter.pdf ). The AAM has similar guidelines. Collectively, the guidance of AAMD and AAM constitute the best practices for museums to follow in dealing with objects that may have been subjected to Nazi art looting or other forms of theft during the Nazi era. These guidelines call on museums to research the provenance of works of art in their collections that could have been looted and to publish the results of their research, preferably on the Internet, so it can be widely accessible. The United States government signed the Washington Principles in 1998 and the Terezin Declaration just this year, to emphasize this country's commitment to just and fair handling of artwork that could have been subject to Nazi looting.

Mr. Edsel first became curious about the two paintings in 2006 after completing research for his first book, Rescuing da Vinci (Laurel Publishing, 2006), a photographic telling of the story of the Monuments Men. Having discovered two archival photos which included images of these two paintings by Murillo, Mr. Edsel wondered how it was possible that two paintings he knew to be at the Meadows Museum could have had a Nazi provenance when there was no mention of it in the Meadows' records. In 2006, Mr. Edsel hired one of the nation's leading provenance researchers, Ms. Patricia Teter, from the Getty Research Institute. Ms. Teter has more than 16 years of experience focused on provenance issues, of which the past six have concentrated on Nazi looting. In March 2007, believing that the Meadows' provenance for the paintings was incorrect, Mr. Edsel and Ms. Teter sought to confirm their documentation by examining the paintings, which occurred on April 30, 2007. To the surprise of Meadows Museum officials, who readily made the paintings available for examination, the Nazi ERR code was visible on the stretcher of Saint Justa; it appeared that the Nazi ERR code had been rubbed off the same position on the stretcher of Saint Rufina. Mr. Edsel subsequently provided a copy of the research that his team had compiled to Meadows Museum officials. In keeping with the Mission Statement of the Monuments Men Foundation (http://www.monumentsmenfoundation.org/about), Mr. Edsel also brought to the attention of University officials the importance of observing the AAM/ AAMD and Washington Principle guidelines governing the identification of works of art stolen by the Nazis, particularly those concerning the need to research the provenance of works of art that could have been subject to Nazi looting, and then publishing those research results. He urged them, and other University officials, to make a joint announcement about these findings to serve as a source of encouragement for all museums to comply with these important guidelines. The Meadows Museum's recent update to its website now makes a definitive statement in support of those guidelines.

In recent months, as Mr. Edsel was completing research for his newly released book about the Monuments Men, he discovered that one of the key figures, Monuments officer Lt. James J. Rorimer, was the person who actually located one of the two stolen Murillo paintings, Saint Justa. In his book, Mr. Edsel quoted Rorimer's reaction to finding the painting by Murillo, along with 157 other stolen works, at a Nazi restoration studio in Buxheim, Germany: "There are few museums in the world that could boast a collection such as the one we found here. Works of art could no longer be thought of in ordinary terms---a roomful, a car load, a castle full, were the quantities we had to reckon with." The other Murillo painting, "Saint Rufina", along with thousands of other priceless works of art including Michelangelo's Bruges "Madonna" and Jan van Eyck's "Ghent Altarpiece", was found by Monuments Men Robert Posey, Lincoln Kirstein, and George Stout at a salt mine in Altaussee, Austria that stored many of the works of art destined for Hitler's planned "Fuehrermuseum".

In addition to his work as an author and as the President of the Monuments Men Foundation, Mr. Edsel was also the co-producer of a documentary film entitled The Rape of Europa, based on the definitive book about Nazi looting by scholar Lynn H. Nicholas. Mr. Edsel is also the publisher of Beyond the Dreams of Avarice (Laurel Publishing, 2009), the definitive catalogue of the painting collection of Nazi Reichsmarschall Hermann Goering, by scholar Nancy H. Yeide. Mr. Edsel is a graduate of Southern Methodist University (1979), served as a Meadows Advisory Board member from 2003-2005, and has been a financial donor and lender to the Museum prior to these developments. He played an instrumental role in the passage of a Resolution by both Houses of Congress, on June 6, 2007, which for the first time recognized by the United States the service of all 350 or so Monuments officers from 13 nations. In November 2007, Mr. Edsel and the Monuments Men Foundation made a donation to the National Archives of the "Hitler Albums", two albums of photographs of works of art stolen by the Nazi looting agency, the ERR, and then presented to Hitler. Both of the Hitler Albums had been in the possession of the estate of an American soldier who took them from Hitler's home in Berchtesgaden in early May 1945. Chief Archivist of the United States, Professor Allen Weinstein, characterized the Hitler Albums as "one of the most significant finds related to Hitler's premeditated theft of art and other cultural treasures to be found since the Nuremberg trials." Mr. Edsel is a recognized expert on the history of the Monuments Men and frequently speaks on this subject including recent presentations at the Art Institute of Chicago and the National World War II Museum in New Orleans.

Southern Methodist University | Monuments Men Foundation | Robert M. Edsel | Nazi Looted Paintings | Nazi ERR (Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg) Code |


Last Week News

October 22, 2009

FIAC to Offer 25 Museum-Quality Artworks with Multimillion-Dollar Price Tags

Rocco Landesman Announces "Art Works" Tour, First Stop: Illinois

Rubens Challenges the Old Masters at the Alte Pinakothek

Peter Greenaway's New Film Offers Fierce Criticism of Today's Visual Illiteracy

Important and Iconic Works from the Masters of Asian Art at Christie's

Guggenheim in Bilbao Celebrates Frank Lloyd Wright with Exhibition

Museum Collection's Storage System Revolutionized by Collaboration

Bust of Roman Emperor Caracalla for Sale at Bonhams

Wayne Hemingway Invites an Army of Local DJs to Take Over Tate Liverpool

Guggenheim and Google Announce Winners of Global Design Competition

Christie's to Present an Important Auction of Orientalist Masterpieces in London

Major Exhibition to Paint a New Picture of Queen Victoria

MFAH Secures First European Presentation of Adolpho Leirner Collection

Museum für Moderne Kunst Frankfurt Shows Photographs by Barbara Klemm

First Solo Exhibition in Paris for Tris Vonna-Michell at Jeu de Paume

James Ensor's Profound Paintings on View at Musée d'Orsay

British Museum Opens Revolution on Paper: Mexican Prints 1910-1960

Bust of Radical Lawmaker Passed to the National Museum Cardiff

Archaeologists Unveil Ancient Auditorium in Rome

Museum Presents Retrospective Exploring the Achievement of Arshile Gorky

October 21, 2009

First Monographic Exhibition on Juan Bautista Maíno at the Museo del Prado

American Figurative Artist and Feminist, Nancy Spero, Dies at 83

A Masterwork by a Renaissance Genius: Raphael to be Offered at Christie's

Sotheby's Fall Sales of Impressionist and Modern Art to Be Held in New York

Exhibition of Spanish Painting and Sculpture Opens at the National Gallery

AP Says Shepard Fairey Made Up Story About Obama Poster

Anish Kapoor Installation Opens as Part of Museum's 50th

Landmark Exhibition Devoted to Art of Samurai Opens at Metropolitan Museum

Tate and Legacy Trust UK Announce First Ever Tate Movie

Survey Finds Out More People Visit Museums During the Recession

Emerging Leaders in the U.S. Museum Community Selected as 2010 Fellows

California Abstract Expressionist Works Given to the Crocker Art Museum

Major Exhibition at Design Museum Celebrates David Chipperfield's Work

Musée d'Orsay Revives Art Nouveau in Exhibition Opening Today

Old Guard: New York State Auctioning Historic Armories

The Soverign Art Foundation and the Barbican Centre Announce New Partnership

Rembrandt, Tiepolo, Van Gogh, Picasso and More at the Dulwich Picture Gallery

National Gallery of Australia Opens Exhibition to Honour Senior Indigenous Emerging Artists

Saint Louis Art Museum Opens Five Centuries of Japanese Screens

Cleveland Museum's Amelia Earhart 'Hair' just Thread

October 20, 2009

Major Exhibition Devoted to "The Torments of Passion: The Dark Side of Sexual Desire"

Sackler Gallery Offers First Exhibition of Rare Manuscripts

Chateau de Versailles Devotes a Large Scale Exhibition to Louis XIV

Prominent Collections & Rare Masterpieces Highlight Christie's Sales

Organizers Say ArtPrize to Return to Grand Rapids in 2010

Museo Picasso Málaga Opens Sophie Taeuber-Arp Retrospective

Breton Masterpiece Returns to the Frick Art & Historical Center for Limited Time

Clear Evidence of Renewed Confidence at Frieze Art Fair 2009

Gail Harrity Appointed President and COO of the Philadelphia Musem of Art

Works by Ruscha and Warhol to Highlight Fall Auction of Fine Prints at Bonhams

Park Service to Take on Bill Clinton's First Home in Arkansas

Gap House Designed by Pitman Tozer Architects Wins the Manser Medal 2009

Cult Film 'The Third Man' Starring Orson Welles Lives on in Vienna Tours

The Smithsonian's Sackler Gallery Extends World Tour of "Garden and Cosmos" to Australia

Legendary Photographer Emmet Gowin Celebrated in New Exhibition

Museum in Pasadena Shows Major Survey of Paintings by Wayne Thiebaud

Boston University Art Gallery to Present Designs for Domestic Architecture from Historic New England

Ashery (Born West Jerusalem, Israel) Collaborates with Sansour (Born East Jerusalem, Palestine) at Tate Modern

El Ray, a Small Holiday House, Wins the Stephen Lawrence Prize 2009

Writing not on the Wall for Lisbon Graffiti Artists

October 19, 2009

Bilbao Fine Arts Museum Exhibition Focuses on Crucial Period in Murillo's Career

Richard Rogers' Maggie's Cancer Care Centre has Won the RIBA Stirling Prize 2009

FIAC 2009 Art Fair Draws Contemporary Art Focus to Paris

Paris Photo 2009 to Spotlight Arab and Iranian Photography

The Footprints of the Builders of the Lod Mosaic were Exposed

Museum in Paris Shows Works by Artists Aware that Death was Imminent

New Survey Book of Contemporary African Art Since 1980

Thatcher Projects Opens Exhibition of New Work by Bill Thompson

National Gallery of Victoria Presents Exhibition of Photographic Works

Georgia Museum of Art Wins Three Publication Awards

Painter Peter Doig and Pianist Stephen Hough Collaborate for One Evening

Eli Wilner Reframes Winslow Homer's Old Mill for the Yale University Art Gallery

Boca Raton Museum Announces Re-Accreditation by AAM

The Art of Socialist Realism at Jeschke-Van Vliet in Berlin

Legendary Fashion Icon Holds Court at Peabody Essex Museum

First Survey of the Early Work by Sean Landers to be Shown in St. Louis

Hello World! Features Rarely Seen Works from Museum's Collection

Spencer Museum Assembles Recent Work by Video Artists Working in Asia

Feminine Figurative Works Grace Michener Art Museum's Outdoor Sculpture Garden this Winter

Exhibition to Show the Glasgow School of Art in the Early Twentieth Century

October 18, 2009

Warhol/Icon: The Creation of Image on View at The Byzantine & Christian Museum

Shepard Fairey Admits Using Key AP Photo for 'HOPE' Poster

Exhibition at Museum of Fine Arts, Boston to Unlock the Secrets of Tomb 10A

Exhibition Commemorates 10th Anniversary of the National Design Awards

Indianapolis Museum of Art Announced Staffers will Face Furloughs

SOFA Chicago Returns to Navy Pier's Festival Hall for Its 16th Year

Exhibition at the Minneapolis Institute of Arts Explores Concepts of "Masterpiece"

Dornier Museum Friedrichshafen Presents James Turrell's Light Installation

First Major Exhibition in Yerevan of Original Work by Artist Arshile Gorky

First Comprehensive Retrospective of Elizabeth Peyton's Oeuvre in Maastricht

Museum Celebrates 25th Anniversary with Arnaldo Roche Rabell Exhibition

LACMA Presents First Major Museum Showing of Indian Comics

MFAH Presents Most Comprehensive US Exhibition of Korean Photography

Brett Weston: Out of the Shadow at the Currier Museum of Art

Photography Installation at the Columbia Museum of Art Features Larry Clark's Gritty Images

Acquisition Enhances Gilcrease Museum's C.M. Russell Collection

Fundación Mapfre Presents Three Major Exhibitions to Mark the Start of the Season

Mirror, Mirror on the Gallery Wall: Contemporary Art Exhibition at BYU

Rare Works from the Masters Lead Christie's Fall Chinese Paintings Sale

New Berkeley Art Space Offers Eclectic Art Event on the Eve of the Day of the Dead

October 17, 2009

Museum of Fine Arts in Seville Shows Duchess of Alba's Private Art Collection

Major Retrospective of Ed Ruscha's Paintings at the Hayward Gallery

Celebrated Works by Warhol and Johns Lead Sale of Prints and Multiples

Man Who Reported Stolen Warhols Waives Insurance

Exhibition at Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, to Offer Rare Show of Paintings

Shepard Fairey and Steve Shames Partner to Benefit Orphans in Uganda

Erwin Wurm Turns Real Objects into Sculptures at the Lenbachhaus

Steven Charles Holds His Second Solo Exhibition at Marlborough

Kunsthaus Zürich to Show 'Van Gogh, Cézanne, Monet - The Bührle Collection'

City of Dallas to Dazzle with New Performing Arts District

The Great Inca Road, A Spectacular Photography Exhibition

Rarity and Beauty of Asian Art at Christie's London this November

Sotheby's Sales of 20th Century Italian Art and Contemporary Art Realize $32,799,234

Internationally-Acclaimed Artist Makes U.S. Solo Debut at Peabody-Essex Museum

National Gallery of Canada Pays Tribute to Kinngait Studio Artists

Museum in St.Louis Announces New Exhibition by Stephen Prina

Sotheby's Four-Day Romano Sale Achieves $15,435,780

Aboriginal Artwork for Vancouver Olympics Medals

21c Museum Hotel in Louisville, KY Voted #1 Hotel in U.S.

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Mexican archaeologists study cave paintings found in the northeast part of Argentina

2.- Exhibition of nude photography around 1900 on view at Berlin's Photography Museum

3.- Top of the bill: Giant rubber duck by Dutch artist Florentijn Hofman sails into Hong Kong

4.- Researchers say first permanent English settlers in America resorted to cannibalism

5.- Russia's great museums feud over revival plan of Moscow museum of Western art

6.- Dartmouth's Hood Museum appoints first African Art Curator

7.- Survey exhibition of American artist Ellen Gallagher's work opens at Tate Modern

8.- Exhibition of nude photography around 1900 on view at Berlin's Photography Museum

9.- Paris Photo Los Angeles concludes a successful first edition with over 13,500 visitors

10.- Excavation unearths evidence of Thessaloniki's urban life between 4th and 9th centuries AD

Related Stories



SMU'S Meadows School of the Arts Announces Recipients of Second Annual Meadows Prize

SMU'S Meadows School of the Arts Announces Recipients of Second Annual Meadows Prize



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Rmz. - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Web Developer: Gabriel Sifuentes - Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi
Special Advisor: Carlos Amador - Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias
Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site