The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Sunday, May 19, 2013
 
Smithsonian Institution's Governing Board Seeks Changes After Video Flap at Portrait Gallery
John McCarter, a member of the Smithsonian Board of Regents, right, gestures during a news conference with Wayne Clough, Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, left, and Patty Stonesifer, chair of the Smithsonian Board of Regents, following a meeting of the Smithsonian Board of Regents Monday, Jan. 31, 2011, in Washington, where they discussed the decision to remove the video "A Fire in My Belly" from the National Portrait Gallery after complaints from a Catholic group. AP Photo/Evan Vucci.

By: Brett Zongker, Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP).- The Smithsonian Institution's governing board on Monday called for changes in how potentially objectionable exhibits are handled while also standing behind the head of the museum complex amid accusations of censorship.

Smithsonian Secretary Wayne Clough came under fire after deciding a couple months ago to remove a gay artist's video that depicted ants crawling on a crucifix in an exhibit at the National Portrait Gallery. The scene angered some in Congress and a Catholic group that called it sacrilegious.

The board said it must be prepared to handle museum disputes and guard freedom of curators in the face of political pressure from Congress or other groups.

"We're in the business of often doing exhibits that are about flash points in American history, flash points in American culture, and we have to accept that with that responsibility comes some controversy," said Patricia Stonesifer, chairwoman of the Smithsonian Board of Regents and former CEO of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. "We don't want curators or directors or others to think that 'above all, avoid controversy.'"

The video in question, "A Fire in My Belly," by the late David Wojnarowicz, explored the subject of AIDS. The artist later died of the disease at age 37 in 1992. The Catholic League called the video sacrilegious.

It was among more than 100 pieces in the first major exhibit to explore gay themes in art history. Other contributing artists are Andy Warhol, Jasper Johns, Thomas Eakins and Annie Leibovitz.

A panel convened to review the handling of the exhibit, "Hide/Seek: Difference and Desire in American Portraiture," included Harvard University professor David Gergen, National Gallery of Art Director Earl A. Powell and Smithsonian regent John McCarter of Chicago's Field Museum.

The panel's key finding was that unless there is an error, changes should not be made to future exhibits once they are opened without curators, museum directors and leaders from the Smithsonian's governing board consulting. It also recommended that the Smithsonian seek public input during the planning of potentially objectionable exhibits and engage Congress as well.

"There are a number of things that with 20/20 hindsight probably could have been done differently," McCarter said. He added that he did not believe including the Wojnarowicz video was a mistake, though with more time to explain the context of the crucifix image to critics, "we might have worked through this."

"Representation of the crucifix and the ants had an interpretation to it, I believe in his mind that was not sacrilegious," McCarter said, noting that the artist was working at the time in Mexico where Christian iconography is often represented in art. "Alternatively, it might have been very deeply religious."

Earlier Monday, about 30 protesters, many from the New York-based group Art Positive, picketed outside the Smithsonian board's meeting and called for Clough to step down. They chanted "No more censorship — Clough must go."

Stuart Wilber, 72, said he traveled from Seattle to see the exhibit, "Hide/Seek: Difference and Desire in American Portraiture," and joined the protest.

"I think censorship in any form is stifling to creativity," Wilber said. "Museums should be bastions of free speech and not subject to political whims."

Arts groups have objected to the Smithsonian's reaction, including the Association of Art Museum Directors, the Andy Warhol Foundation and more recently the Smithsonian's own Hirshhorn Museum board, which wrote last week that bowing to pressure harms the Smithsonian's integrity.

Clough said he respects those who disagree with his decision and said he would respond differently in the future. He said he wants the Smithsonian to be ahead of sensitive topics to handle them more clearly.

"I'd like to think I'm a little wiser than I was six months ago or three months ago," he said.

Bill Dobbs, an organizer with the group Art Positive said he wasn't satisfied with the board's response.

"They may not comprehend the scope of the damage," he said, adding that the Smithsonian had created a "heckler's veto" as a precedent for future exhibits.

Stonesifer said the board had been divided in its reaction to the Wojnarowicz video but didn't vote on whether it should have been included or removed. She said Wojnarowicz had been a significant leader in the art world at a time when little attention was paid to the AIDS epidemic and many of those affected felt political and religious institutions had failed them.

Stonesifer noted other Wojnarowicz works remain in the exhibit. She declined to speculate whether the Smithsonian was damaged more by including his work or by removing the video.

"Would we wish the whole incident hadn't happened? Certainly," she said.


Copyright 2011 The Associated Press.



Last Week News

February 1, 2011

Thirty-Six Splendid, Virtuoso Ivory Carvings on View at Liebieghaus Skulpturensammlung

Smithsonian Institution's Governing Board Seeks Changes After Video Flap at Portrait Gallery

The Museum of Modern Art is One of 17 Museums Participating in Google's Art Project

Pioneers of Modern British Sculpture Offered in Bonhams' 20th Century British Art Sale

Art from China's Forbidden City on View at the Metropolitan Museum in New York

Donald Ellis Achieves Record Sales for Native American Art at New York's Winter Antiques Show

Monet's Water Lilies Offers Rare Opportunity to Experience Great Impressionist's Work as Intended

Representations of Dance in the Art of Modernism at the Sprengel Museum in Hannover

High Museum of Art Announces "Picasso to Warhol: Twelve Modern Masters"

New Video Installation by Diana Thater Fills Interior of Hauser & Wirth's Piccadilly Gallery

MOCA Cleveland Winter Exhibition Features Teresita Fernández Sculptural Installations

Tate Britain Provides a Timely Focus on a Selection of Key Works by Susan Hiller

Steve Case Nominated to Serve as a Citizen Regent on Smithsonian Board of Regents

Photojournalist Lucien Aigner’s Work Re-Emerges in DeCordova Museum Exhibition

Paintings by Brian Rutenberg on Display at the Morris Museum

Smithsonian Board Supports Museum Head

Allentown Art Museum of the Lehigh Valley Announces Re-Opening Season of Special Exhibitions

New and Free App "Take it Artside!" to Bring Kentucky's Art Scene to Wider Audience

New Work by Richard Phillips for His Third Exhibition at White Cube Hoxton Square

Bonhams Launch Modern and Contemporary Israeli Art Sale in London in May

Egypt: Military Detain 50 Men Trying to Break into at Egyptian National Museum

Victoria & Albert Museum in London Says It has Unearthed "Only" Film of Ballets Russes

Erin O'Connor Unveils New Rankin Photos at Portrait Gallery's Fashion Friday Late Opening

Second Annual Collectors Evening Secures Six New Acquisitions for the High

Mint Condition Factory-Sealed Beatles 'Butcher Cover' Mono LP Could Bring Record Price

Red Dot Art Fair Announce its Return to New York City in Newly Renovated Event Space

Tracks of Two Prehistoric Birds Found in Alaska

CAFAM Announces New Leadership MOCA's Suzanne Isken Takes The Reins

Portland Museum of Art Offers Innovative New Membership Initiative

January 31, 2011

Specific Objects without Specific Form by Felix Gonzalez-Torres at MMK in Frankfurt

Erin O'Connor Unveils New Rankin Photographs at National Portrait Gallery's Fashion Friday Late Opening

Victoria & Albert Museum in London Says It has Unearthed "Only" Film of Ballets Russes

Egypt: Military Detain 50 Men Trying to Break into at Egyptian National Museum

New Work by Richard Phillips for His Third Exhibition at White Cube Hoxton Square

Bonhams Launch Modern and Contemporary Israeli Art Sale in London in May

New and Free App "Take it Artside!" to Bring Kentucky's Art Scene to Wider Audience

Dancing with the Dark: Joan Snyder Prints 1963-2010 at the Zimmerli Art Museum

Thorburn Partridges Soar to £192,000 at Bonhams 19th Century Paintings Sale

DeCordova Sculpture Park and Museum Exhibition Features Early Computer-Generated Art

Red Dot Art Fair Announce its Return to New York City in Newly Renovated Event Space

Mint Condition Factory-Sealed Beatles 'Butcher Cover' Mono LP Could Bring Record Price at Heritage Auctions

Second Annual Collectors Evening Secures Six New Acquisitions for the High

Cultural Identity and Pattern Collide in Exhibition at Kemper Museum of Contemporary Art

Works by Michelangelo Part of Florida Vatican Exhibit at Museum of Art Fort Lauderdale

American Debut Solo Show of Berlin Artist Lars Theuerkauff at Cain Schulte Contemporary Art

New Exhibition at the Crocker Art Museum Surveys the Art of Gottfried Helnwein

Louvre Presents First Exhibition of Austrian Sculptor Franz Xaver Messerschmidt

Four New, Monumental Paintings by Brazilian Artist Beatriz Milhazes at Fondation Beyeler

Taxing Visions: Financial Episodes in Late 19th-Century American Art Opens at the Huntington

Velázquez Loan Marks Second Month of Dulwich Picture Gallery's Bicentenary

150 Years Later: New Photography by Tina Barney, Tim Davis, and Katherine Newbegin

The Sixties Swing Again for Exhibition at the Arts University College at Bournemouth

Newly Restored Rooms will Amaze the Easter Visitor to Neo-Classical Palace Stowe House

Saint Louis Art Museum Marks One Year on Expansion

Denver Art Museum Brings Artists' Voices to the Forefront

Indianapolis Museum of Art to Reconfigure Third Floor Galleries

1960 Les Paul Sunburst Expected to Bring $100,000+ in Vintage Guitar Event at Heritage Auctions

January 30, 2011

Singer Laren Restores Auguste Rodin's The Thinker After It was Damaged When Stolen

The Art of Light: Works by László Moholy-Nagy at the Gemeentemuseum Den Haag

The Vorticists: Rebel Artists in London and New York at the Peggy Guggenheim Collection

Thomas Gainsborough and the Modern Woman in Exhibition at the San Diego Museum of Art

Anti-Government Protesters in Cairo Smash Treasures and Mummies in Egyptian Museum

Sports Illustrated Presents Neil Leifer's For the Love of the Game at PDNB Gallery

First Retrospective of Jim Dine's Sculpture Opens at Frederik Meijer Gardens & Sculpture Park

Krannert Art Museum in Illinois Kicks Off 50th Anniversary Season with Exhibition

The Ptarmigan Vase: A Unique Treasure Enters National Gallery of Canada's Collection

Bruce Museum Opens Exhibition "Cindy Sherman: Works from Friends of the Bruce Museum"

Hammer Museum's Sixth Biennial Invitational Highlights Los Angeles and International Artists

Exhibition of Select Images from Cui Xiuwen's Most Important Series at Blindspot Gallery

Photographs of Native Americans by Herbert Ascherman at the Butler Institute of American Art

Jim Nutt: Coming Into Character on View at the Museum of Contemporary Art, Chicago

Norton Museum of Art Celebrates 70th with Free Birthday Bash

Maurer Zilioli Contemporary Arts Presents Limbo by Silvia Beltrami

Cincinnati Art Museum Partners with 21c Museum Hotel

Baldknobbers to Donate Artifacts to Smithsonian Pioneering Variety Show from One of America's Entertainment Capitals

Artist and Composer Ryoji Ikeda to Create Immersive Visual and Sonic Installation for Armory's Vast Drill Hall

Getty Acquires Significant Group of South African Photographs

January 29, 2011

Seventy Impressive Black-and-White Drawings by Roy Lichtenstein on View at Albertina

Nefertiti's Bust will Stay in German Capital Says Berlin Mayor Klaus Wowereit

Egypt Army Secures Egyptian Museum with Pharaonic Treasures: Report from Cairo

Group Wants Smithsonian Secretary Wayne Clough's Ouster Over Banned Video

Rembrandt Portrait, Which Sold at Christie's in 2009, to Be Offered for $47 Million

British Sculpture Survey at the Royal Academy in London Sharply Divides Critics

Selling Exhibition of Key Modern British Sculpture at Robert Bowman Modern

Joel and Lila Harnett Museum of Art Presents Pilgrimage and Faith: Buddhism Christianity and Islam

Brooklyn-Based Artist and Photographer Lorna Simpson Opens Solo Exhibition at Brooklyn Museum

Exhibition of Drawings and Sculptures by Italian Artist Marisa Merz at Gladstone Gallery

Tasende Gallery Presents Exhibition of Sculptures and Drawings by Mark di Suvero

Art Institute of Chicago Announces Significant Acquisition of Seminal Kazimir Malevich Painting

Louvre Hosts a Group of Sculptures by Leading British Contemporary Artist Tony Cragg

Rachel Perry Welty's First Museum Solo Exhibition Opens at deCordova

Wonderful New Tool for those Who Have Always Wanted to Draw but Didn't Know How

Shimon Attie's Exhibition MetroPAL.IS Debuts at The Aldrich Contemporary Art Museum

Madison Square Park Conservancy to Receive Prestigious U.S. Art Critics Association Award

Mass Sketchers Turn the World to Art in a Day

Jefferson's Monticello Makes Ale Inspired by Past

Unmarked Graves Found at Veteran Cemetery in Mississippi

January 28, 2011

Major Exhibition of Spanish Art at the Dawn of the 20th Century at Fondation de l'Hermitage

Tasende Gallery Presents Exhibition of Sculptures and Drawings by Mark di Suvero

Art Institute of Chicago Announces Significant Acquisition of Seminal Kazimir Malevich Painting

Louvre Hosts a Group of Sculptures by Leading British Contemporary Artist Tony Cragg

Rembrandt Portrait, Which Sold at Christie's in 2009, to Be Offered for $47 Million

British Sculpture Survey at the Royal Academy in London Sharply Divides Critics

Selling Exhibition of Key Modern British Sculpture at Robert Bowman Modern

Joel and Lila Harnett Museum of Art Presents Pilgrimage and Faith: Buddhism Christianity and Islam

Brooklyn-Based Artist and Photographer Lorna Simpson Opens Solo Exhibition at Brooklyn Museum

Exhibition of Drawings and Sculptures by Italian Artist Marisa Merz at Gladstone Gallery

The Romanovs, Tsars and Art Collectors at the Pinacotheque de Paris

Auction Record Set for Titian at Sotheby's Old Master Paintings Sale in New York

Statues Devastated in World War II Go on Show at the Pergamon Museum in Berlin

Henry Scott Tuke Painting of a Sleeping Sailor to Sell at Bonhams

Museo d'Arte Moderna di Bologna Presents Matthew Day Jackson Exhibition

The Bronx Museum of the Arts Presents Exhibition Exploring Work of Elizabeth Catlett

Christie's 2010 Global Art Sales Total $5.0 Billion, Highest Sales Total in History

An Evening Sale of South African Masterpieces at Bonhams in London

Jon Stewart to Join 9/11 Memorial Foundation Board

Milwaukee Art Museum, Carnegie Museum of Art Wager Masterpiece on Super Bowl XLV

Team of Researchers Says Humans May Have Left Africa Earlier than Thought

Bronzino & Portraits of Power Exhibition at the Palazzo Strozzi Attracts 230,000

Malmo Konsthall Presents Exhibition Presents Photographs by Ake Hedstrom

Paul Kasmin Presents Dual Exhibition of New Works and Iconic Paintings by Kenny Scharf

Indeterminate Stillness: Berkeley Art Museum Exhibition Looks at James McNeill Whistler

Trove of Previously Unseen Letters Written by J.D. Salinger Reveal His Human Side

British Museum and Rio Tinto Announce Australian Season: Broad Program of Exhibitions

Italy's Largest and Most Important Art Fair Arte Fiera Art First Celebrates Contemporary Art

January 27, 2011

Christie's Two-Part Sale of Old Master & 19th Century Art Totals a Combined $36,671,625

Plate Painted by Pablo Picasso Donated to Ransom Center by Photojournalist Duncan

Sotheby's Contemporary Art Evening Sale to Debut Ai Weiwei's 'Sunflower Seeds' at Auction

Richard P. Townsend Steps Down as President and CEO of the Museum of Latin American Art

Italy's Largest and Most Important Art Fair Arte Fiera Art First Celebrates Contemporary Art

British Museum and Rio Tinto Announce Australian Season: Broad Program of Exhibitions

Trove of Previously Unseen Letters Written by J.D. Salinger Reveal His Human Side

Indeterminate Stillness: Berkeley Art Museum Exhibition Looks at James McNeill Whistler

Paul Kasmin Presents Dual Exhibition of New Works and Iconic Paintings by Kenny Scharf

Malmo Konsthall Presents Exhibition Presents Photographs by Ake Hedstrom

Christie's 2010 Global Art Sales Total $5.0 Billion, Highest Sales Total in History

The Bronx Museum of the Arts Presents Exhibition Exploring Work of Elizabeth Catlett

Museo d'Arte Moderna di Bologna Presents Matthew Day Jackson Exhibition

LACMA Announced Today the Retirement of President and COO Melody Kanschat

SFMOMA's 2011 Auction Features Work by Artists with Strong Ties to the Museum

Memorial at Site of Auschwitz Oven Builders

Notable Names Highlight Clars February 2011 Auction

New Museum Presents First Major United States Survey of Works by George Condo

New Exhibit Unveiled in Royal Ontario Museum's Patricia Harris Gallery of Textiles & Costume

Eighty Images by Vivian Maier from the 50's and 60's at Hilaneh von Kories Gallery

Clark Art Institute to Launch First International Tour of Masterpieces from the Collection

Prendergast Works Loaned to Milwaukee Art Museum

From North Korea Propaganda to Art Exhibit in Seoul, Defector Song Byeok Shows His Work

Virginia Historian Thomas P. Lowry Denies Tampering with Abraham Lincoln Pardon

Mile-Long Floating Walkway Above the Thames to Open Up London's Hidden Past

RM Auctions Selects Salon Privé at Syon Park for All New "Quintessentially English" UK Sale

Iconic Little House on the Prairie Artwork Readies for Illustration Art Event at Heritage Auctions

Clara Kim to Join Walker Art Center as Senior Curator of Visual Arts

Adrian Ghenie at Tim Van Laere Gallery, Antwerp

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Mexican archaeologists study cave paintings found in the northeast part of Argentina

2.- Exhibition of nude photography around 1900 on view at Berlin's Photography Museum

3.- Top of the bill: Giant rubber duck by Dutch artist Florentijn Hofman sails into Hong Kong

4.- Researchers say first permanent English settlers in America resorted to cannibalism

5.- Russia's great museums feud over revival plan of Moscow museum of Western art

6.- Dartmouth's Hood Museum appoints first African Art Curator

7.- Survey exhibition of American artist Ellen Gallagher's work opens at Tate Modern

8.- Exhibition of nude photography around 1900 on view at Berlin's Photography Museum

9.- Paris Photo Los Angeles concludes a successful first edition with over 13,500 visitors

10.- Excavation unearths evidence of Thessaloniki's urban life between 4th and 9th centuries AD



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Rmz. - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Web Developer: Gabriel Sifuentes - Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi
Special Advisor: Carlos Amador - Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias
Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site