Error: 3002 Source: GeoIP.asp line 56: File could not be opened. Turkey tweaks cult of national founder
The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 Monday, May 20, 2013
 
Turkey tweaks cult of national founder
In this March 30, 2012 file photo released by Sitki Kahvecioglu Foundation, Sitki Kahvecioglu, left, and a friend pose in front of the statue of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk in Artvin, Turkey. A 22-meter (72-foot) high copper statue of Ataturk — the country's biggest of the iconic figure — was inaugurated on May 19 in northeastern Turkey, a tribute to the near-mystical hold that Ataturk exerts over his fervent believers, whose admiration is rooted in his success in imposing secular values on a largely Muslim nation. Yet the cult of Ataturk, once a staple of Turkish state ideology, is slowly, sometimes imperceptibly, being diluted, replaced in part by the Ottoman imperial era as inspiration for an Islamist-rooted government with its own set of ideas about modernity, morality and regional stature. AP Photo/Sitki Kahvecioglu Foundation, File.

By: Christopher Torchia and Emrah Betos, Associated Press

ISTANBUL (AP).- On a trip to Rio de Janeiro, a Turkish notary public gazed at the Christ the Redeemer statue that looms over the Brazilian city and was inspired to build a monumental likeness of his idol: Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, Turkey's independence war hero and national founder.

"I said to myself: 'Jesus Christ is a great man, but my Ataturk is as great as him,'" said 78-year-old Sitki Kahvecioglu, who fulfilled his dream 15 years later.

A 22-meter (72-foot) high copper statue of Ataturk — the country's biggest of the iconic figure — was inaugurated on May 19 in northeastern Turkey, a tribute to the near-mystical hold that Ataturk exerts over his fervent believers, whose admiration is rooted in his success in imposing secular values on a largely Muslim nation.

Yet the cult of Ataturk, once a staple of Turkish state ideology, is slowly, sometimes imperceptibly, being diluted, replaced in part by the Ottoman imperial era as inspiration for an Islamist-rooted government with its own set of ideas about modernity, morality and regional stature.

To be sure, Ataturk, whose surname means "father of the Turks," is still seemingly everywhere more than 70 years after his death.

His face is on banknotes. His piercing eyes and widow's peak adorn framed portraits in public offices, and many shops and homes. His sarcophagus lies in a giant mausoleum in the capital, Ankara. Istanbul's main international airport is named after him. Turkish law says it is a crime to insult his name, though prosecutions have eased up in recent years.

But Turkey is a nation in the grip of an astonishing transformation, and such official reverence appears increasingly out of sync with the times.

Today's Turkey is a democracy grappling with an authoritarian legacy, a market economy whose explosive growth in the past decade is the bedrock of newfound swagger and a Western ally with historical and cultural links to the Middle East that place it at the forefront of debate about the change sweeping the region.

It is also led by pious Muslims whose electoral triumphs drained power from military-backed classes that championed the code of Ataturk, who pulled together a nation from the wreckage of the Ottoman Empire, diminished Islam's influence by decree, welded Turkish ethnicity to national identity and reinforced the power of the state over the individual. The current government has sought to soften that credo, preserving Ataturk as a national icon but chipping away at the idea that his word, and traditional expressions of homage, are inviolable.

"In the past, to say 'Ataturk said so' would be the end of the discussion," said Mustafa Akyol, author of "Islam without Extremes: A Muslim Case for Liberty."

Now, Akyol said, more people are willing to challenge Ataturk's precepts, and as a result, followers of his ideology, known as Kemalism, "are becoming more insecure and that sometimes makes them even more insistent about keeping the symbols."

One example of tension-tinged change came on May 19, the anniversary of the day in 1919 that is celebrated as the beginning of the Turkish fight for nationhood — with Ataturk, who only later acquired that surname, at the center of the narrative. For the first time, the militarism of past celebrations was replaced with civilian events hailed by government officials as more inclusive. In Istanbul, a ceremony in front of a statue of Ataturk skipped the traditional moment of silence held in his honor and a band played the national anthem. Some onlookers were outraged, shouting: "We want respect for Ataturk."

Howard Eissenstat, an academic at St. Lawrence University in the United States who is working on a book about the roots of Turkish nationalism, said that some Turks distrust the ruling party for challenging "longstanding definitions of what being a Turk is." He traced the start of this conflict to the 1950 election victory of an opposition group over a party founded by Ataturk, who died in 1938, in a process that accelerated with the opening up of the economy in the late 1980s.

Eissenstat compared Turkey's "cultural war" to what some American conservatives have called a "war on Christmas" — recent disputes in the United States over whether Christmas should be observed as a secular or religious holiday in public settings. He also noted that the willingness of Turkish leaders to acknowledge official wrongdoing in a deadly bombing campaign aimed at crushing a Kurdish rebellion in the 1930s reflected an indirect way of tarnishing the reputation of Turkey's premier historical hero.

"They're highlighting the ways that Mustafa Kemal was directly implicated in crimes," he said. "They see Mustafa Kemal as somebody with a complex historical legacy. They don't feel that he should be at the center of policy, and they certainly don't think that rituals that prioritize the military should be at the center."

Tansel Colasan, president of a foundation that promotes the national founder, wrote in an email that it was "unfortunate" that the leaders of military coups in 1971 and 1980 claimed to act in the name of Ataturk. She also criticized the "jargon of radical/fanatic pro-Islamic media" that has recently denigrated Ataturk, saying it ignores how he laid the foundations of a country that is a symbol of "peace and stability" in the Middle East.

The government of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, sometimes accused of illiberal tendencies and score-settling, says it is committed to secular politics and intent on joining the European Union despite a troubled candidacy for membership. At the same time, it has presided over a flourishing of pride in the Islam-based, Ottoman empire and perceptions, open to dispute, that its rulers were tolerant and pluralistic. Old mosques have been restored, Ottoman-era calligraphy is back in style as an art form and period television dramas are popular in Turkey and beyond its borders.

But there is only one guiding light for Kahvecioglu, who poured his savings into the $2.2 million statue of Ataturk in Artvin, his hometown near Georgia. It depicts Ataturk in uniform and a high cap, hunched forward, apparently in deep thought during a campaign against a Greek army just before Turkey was founded in 1923.

Kahvecioglu said he carried firewood from the mountains as a child, went to law school, ran unsuccessfully for mayor, did business for one of Turkey's richest men and ran a charity foundation that built facilities in Artvin. He dismissed criticism on the Internet that he was an idol-worshipper who should have spent the statue funds on the poor. "I was always a rebel against injustice," he said.

And a new generation of Turks is growing up with Ataturk, even if the national adulation is not what it was. Every morning, children in elementary school recite an oath that includes the line:

"O Great Ataturk! On the path you opened, toward the goal you have shown, I vow to march without hesitation."


Copyright 2012 The Associated Press.



Last Week News

June 11, 2012

Exhibition of over sixty marble statues and preparatory studies by Rodin opens in Paris

Watch Your Step: A group exhibition of floor works on view at The FLAG Art Foundation

Rare Napoleon Bonaparte letter exhibiting English skills sells at auction for $405,000

The Vanity of Small Differences: Victoria Miro's fourth solo exhibition with Grayson Perry opens

Bonhams to offer Tiffany Studio highlights as part of the June 20th Century Decorative Arts Auction

"Tomas Erhart: Deconstructive Nudes" opens at Inner Circle Consultants in Hamburg

Jerusalem Mayor, Nir Barkat confers title of Honorary Citizen of Jerusalem on Israel Museum Director, James Snyder

Sale of colorful Lalique vases at Bonhams includes one of his rarest designs

50 years later, Seattle Center continues to evolve; from a zip line to a new art glass museum

1879 Flowing Hair Stella brings $184,000 to lead Heritage Auctions sale

Artists community grows in Mark Twain's hometown of 18,000 near the Mississippi River

One hundred years after the introduction of the Oreo, plans for historic NYC home drawing fire

Asian art dealers Duchange & Riché open first gallery in the United Kingdom at Grays

Riflemaker presents exhibition of new photographs by Leah Gordon

One of the oldest military flags, the Dettingen Standrard, to be offered in sale of arms and armour

Los Angeles' Getty Museum illustrates death in Middle Ages

Les Paul guitar auction fetches nearly $5M

Detroit museum to host Navy's War of 1812 display

June 10, 2012

Now clean, Lorenzo Ghiberti's 15th-century 'Door of Paradise' goes to Italy museum

Laguna Art Museum opens a retrospective on artist Clarence Hinkle and The Group of Eight

New Jersey-born Artist Dan Colen's first solo exhibition in Paris opens at Gagosian Gallery

First comprehensive exhibition in three decades of George Bellows' prolific career to open at National Gallery of Art

The San Diego Museum of Art presents exhibition of monumental Gothic tapestries

Chopin document selling the copyrights to two of his finest works to his English publishers up for sale

Butler Institute of American Art presents last works by master painter Joan Mitchell

"Seeing the World Within: Charles Seliger in the 1940s" opens at the Peggy Guggenheim Collection, Venice

Prized painting owned by high society writer, editor and painter, Fleur Cowles, for sale at Bonhams

Flip Your Field: Exhibition of Abstract art from the University of Michigan Museum of Art Collection opens

British artist Craigie Horsfield's Slow Time and the Present opens at Kunsthalle Basel

Walter Maciel Gallery opens first solo exhibition of paintings by Colin Doherty

Catalina Island Museum announces Rock n' Roll Symposium dedicated to the British Invasion

Institute for Contemporary Culture celebrates Beethoven's beloved piano sonatas with Luminato

Artistic positions that focus on the critical analysis of violent conflicts in the media at Haus der Kunst

Megan Whitmarsh's rendered sculptural and painted objects on view at Jack Hanley Gallery

Hunterdon Art Museum presents Nancy Cohen: Precarious Exchange

Haroon Mirza awarded Daiwa Foundation Art Prize 2012

June 9, 2012

Exhibition at the Prado Museum focuses on the last seven years of the life of Raphael

Barnett Newman's masterpiece Stations of the Cross is focus of exhibition at National Gallery of Art

Two Yves Klein masterpieces to be offered at Christie's Post-War & Contemporary Art Evening Auction

Cycling, Cubo-Futurism and the 4th Dimension. Jean Metzinger's work at the Peggy Guggenheim Collection

Huntington Library, Art Collections, and Botanical Gardens acquires major Robert Rauschenberg painting

Amon Carter presents American Vanguards: Graham, Davis, Gorky, de Kooning and Their Circle, 1927-1942

Foam opens exhibition of the work by pioneer of paparazzi photography Ron Galella

Real to Real: Photographs from the Traina Collection opens at the de Young Museum

Gene Kelly memorabilia to be offered at Sotheby's Fine Books and Manuscripts sale

Canadian photographer Edward Burtynsky's "Oil" opens at the Nevada Museum of Art

BAM/PFA introduces two new curatorial hires-Apsara DiQuinzio and Philippe Pirotte

Exhibition of Judith Turner's photographs opens at The University of Michigan Museum of Art

Eminent South African anthropologist Tobias dies; excelled in a variety of scientific fields

Recent acquisitions displayed at Nelson-Atkins Museum

Peter Bo Rappmund's first solo exhibition at a museum opens at Laguna Art Museum

Forbidden Castle: A selection of work by Xu Zhen opens at Museum Montanelli in Prague

Local heroes & sporting legends share podium at the Bowes Museum

Building dialoque, bridging communities, portable media rig explores North America

Photographers explore the South in High exhibition

June 8, 2012

Over 150 artists from fifty-five countries gather for dOCUMENTA (13) in Kassel

Guggenheim presents expansive exhibition of mid-20th century art from the permanent collection

Exhibition of large-scale recent drawings by Albert Oehlen opens at Gagosian in Rome

New exhibition at the Morgan explores the brilliance of Winston Churchill's writings and speeches

International exhibition explores impact of photography on Post-Impressionist painters

Bonhams June Native American Art Auction in San Francisco brings a stellar $1.4 million

Kemper Museum in Kansas City names current Curator Barbara O'Brien as Director

"On Vacation with Winslow Homer: Wood Engravings of an American Master" at Morris Museum

First UK solo exhibition of American artist Nancy Holt opens at Haunch of Venison

53 Galleries, the introduction of artists from Spain and Portugal and worldwide launch of PINTA Design

Swiss duo Taiyo Onorato & Nico Krebs open photography exhibition at Foam in Amsterdam

First solo exhibition in the UK of new paintings by the Swedish artist Anna Camner at Faggionato Fine Art

"Dan Walsh: Uncommon Ground" opens at the Rhode Island School of Design Museum of Art

Fake Empire: Olivo Barbieri, Rob Carter, Susan Giles, Dionisio Gonzalez, and Lee Stoetzel at Mixed Greens

South African photographer Pieter Hugo's first retrospective opens at Musée de l'Elysée

World record for leading Indian artist at Bonhams Sale of Modern and Contemporary Souh Asian Art

First major retrospective of seminal figure in the American studio jewelry movement opens

Solo exhibition of new work by Ellen Jong opens at Allegra LaViola

June 7, 2012

Spectacular two thousand year old gold and silver hoard uncovered in an excavation

Sotheby's to offer the most exceptional collection of eight paintings by Frank Auerbach of Ruth Bromberg

Louvre opens exhibition of about one hundred works on paper by Gerhard Richter

16th century masterpiece by Girolamo Romanino achieves $4,562,500 at Christie's

Bernarducci.Meisel.Gallery and Louis K. Meisel Gallery are ALL IN! with new exhibition

Remains of Shakespeare's Curtain Theatre found by archaeologists from the Museum of London

A taste for luxury: Two great houses from America's gilded age to be offered at Christie's

Chris Martin opens first solo exhibiton with Galerie Rodolphe Janssen in Brussels

Prof. Jeffrey Quilter announced as the new Director at the Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology

Britain's first celebrity transvestite...Rare painting acquired by National Portrait Gallery

Science fiction-fantasy master Ray Bradbury, author of 'Fahrenheit 451,' dies

Dorothea Arnold to become Curator Emeritus after 21 years heading department at Metropolitan

Critical Mass: Contemporary art from India on view at the Tel Aviv Museum of Art

Major international honour for Emily Carr: Seven works by Carr on exhibit at prestigious dOCUMENTA (13)

FIGMENT Weekend: 6th annual participatory arts event on Governors Island June 9-10

First solo show in New York City of photography by Mitra Tabrizian opens at Leila Heller Gallery

Elegant Enigmas: The Art of Edward Gorey opens Norton Museum of Art summer season

"Material Matters," a group exhibition featuring four female artists opens at Lyons Wier Gallery

Twenty-five unreleased images by Roger Ballen in exhibition at Musée de l'Elysée

Haroon Mirza's A Sleek Dry Yell (2008) jointly acquired by five public galleries

June 6, 2012

Herzog & de Meuron and Ai Weiwei's Serpentine Gallery Pavilion opens in London

Hammer Galleries, New York presents a Virtual Tour of their exhibition: "On Paper"

Report of first doctor to reach shot Abraham Lincoln found at the National Archives

Andy Warhol's portrait of Karl Ludwig Schweisfurth up for auction at Ketterer Kunst

MoMA makes historic acquisition of thirteen drawings by Henry Darger from the estate of the artist

Group exhibition "Everyday Abstract-Abstract Everyday" on view at James Cohan Gallery

LACMA presents North American premiere of Sharon Lockhart's latest body of work

Sculptures from artist Jun Kaneko's critically acclaimed Heads Series on view in San Francisco

Exquisite offerings in the June Bonhams Fine Jewelry Auction to be held in New York

Washington's Corcoran Gallery of Art considering move, even to suburban Maryland or Virginia

Duesenberg and other convertibles top sellers during Auctions America by RM's Auburn Spring Auction

Kunsthaus Zürich presents 'Time as Perspective'; an exhibition by visual artist Rosa Barba

Madison Square Park Conservancy's Mad. Sq. Art Benefit honors Martin Friedman's 60-year career in the arts

Frank Lloyd Wright window and Chinese cloisonne top 20th Century Design and Decorative Arts events

Wadsworth Atheneum receives $2 million from Connecticut State Bond Commission

Anna Szprynger at the National Gallery of Art in Sopot

Dayton Art Institute announces plans for new community gathering place

Street artist launches two surprise art exhibits, one at MoMA and the other at the Met

New York mayor, agency: Deal near on stalled 9/11 museum

Bulgaria: Skeletons treated for vampirism found

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Mexican archaeologists study cave paintings found in the northeast part of Argentina

2.- Exhibition of nude photography around 1900 on view at Berlin's Photography Museum

3.- Top of the bill: Giant rubber duck by Dutch artist Florentijn Hofman sails into Hong Kong

4.- Researchers say first permanent English settlers in America resorted to cannibalism

5.- Russia's great museums feud over revival plan of Moscow museum of Western art

6.- Dartmouth's Hood Museum appoints first African Art Curator

7.- Survey exhibition of American artist Ellen Gallagher's work opens at Tate Modern

8.- Exhibition of nude photography around 1900 on view at Berlin's Photography Museum

9.- Paris Photo Los Angeles concludes a successful first edition with over 13,500 visitors

10.- Excavation unearths evidence of Thessaloniki's urban life between 4th and 9th centuries AD



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Rmz. - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Web Developer: Gabriel Sifuentes - Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi
Special Advisor: Carlos Amador - Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias
Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site